Monday, 16 November 2026

Countering the cry of the community Part 2: Division or Unity?

 

COUNTERING THE CRY OF THE COMMUNITY

Division or Unity?

Becoming one, though different

 

My wife and I were called out of traditional church into a pioneering role of missional listening in 2017. The first few months were an absolute car crash. I realised I had all the wrong questions and no answers.

I went to Buckfast Abbey and prayed in front of the beautiful stained-glass window of Jesus in vivid colours with his arms outstretched in welcome. I collapsed to my knees and said, “Lord, I have no idea how to be a Christian. All my questions are about doing church well, and I don't know how to lead people to Jesus. I haven't got a clue how to be a minister.” The word I heard back was unexpected: “Finally!”

I had spent much of my ministry creating plans and strategies, outreach projects and evangelism programmes—all with good intentions—and bringing them to the Lord with the request that he bless our endeavours. But that day, perhaps for the first time, I came with the posture: “Lord, you lead and I will follow.”

The biblical imagination took me to the fishermen in the boat at the end of John's Gospel. From the beach comes the shout: “Haven't you caught anything?” The embarrassed reply: “Nothing.” Then comes the divine leading: “Put your net on the other side.” They do, and there is a great catch. It was as though the Lord was saying to me, “You are in the right place. Now let's start doing this my way for a change!”

I returned home with three questions on my heart. The first, inspired by Alan Roxburgh: What is the cry of the community? The second, inspired by Walter Brueggemann: What does the biblical imagination say to that cry? And the third, inspired by Lesslie Newbigin: What would it look like if a group of believers lived the counter of that cry?

These three questions have become the foundation of what I have come to call “countering the cry of the community”. Every culture has stories underneath its stories. They tell us what the world is like, what we need to survive, who we need to be, what we should fear and what will make us happy. Often these stories are so familiar that we barely notice them. They shape our instincts, our hopes and our habits.

What is the cry of the community? As we listen, we begin to hear these underlying stories. And if we are not careful, the church simply absorbs them. We hear the cry of our communities and start to mimic it. We become like the culture around us.

But what if the calling of the church is not to echo the cry? What if we are called to counter it? Not simply to stand outside the world shouting “No!”, but to embody in our everyday lives God's “Yes”. To become a visible alternative. To become a counter-community. A people who show what another way of being human looks like.

There is an important distinction here. Being counter-cultural can sound like being against the world, defined by the things we reject. Becoming a counter-community is something more positive and more demanding. It means becoming a people whose shared life offers a tangible alternative: not merely different opinions, but different relationships, habits, priorities and ways of belonging.

As we listen attentively to our communities, we notice countless cries. They will be different in different places, but as a way of developing this idea I want to explore four that I encounter time and time again. In this post, we will look at division.

Our culture is incredibly good at creating tribes. Us and them. Left and right. This side and that side. People like us and people not like us. Increasingly, the messages in our communities and on the news suggest that “these people are the problem”. And the temptation for the church is to copy it.

If you are a Christian who moves to my town, I could direct you to the church that best suits you. If you want the conservative church, go there; the smells-and-bells church, go there; the inclusive liberal church, go there; the church swinging from the chandeliers, go there. And off you go to your tribe, until you disagree about something—and then perhaps it is on to the next church that most closely matches your own type and ideals.

We become tribal in our churches. We gather with people who agree with us and reinforce one another's opinions. Before long, the church is simply reproducing the divisions of the culture. I have spent much of my Christian life struggling with this disunity: as a child, watching my father, a church secretary, weep as a church split in horrendous ways over a change of worship style; ministering in a church where people praying for Palestine had “Israel” shouted at them in response, or where prayers for Israel were met with “Palestine” shouted aggressively. I have watched the Baptist Union pull itself apart over differing views on same-sex marriage. These are just a few examples. Too often, we mimic the world.

But the Bible tells a very different story. Think about the people Jesus gathers around himself: tax collectors, fishermen and Zealots. They are people who would not naturally have belonged in the same friendship group. The television series The Chosen portrays some of the tensions and differences between the disciples particularly well. Peter and Matthew's relationship is a striking example. Jesus does not simply tolerate their differences; he calls them into a shared life and makes them family.

The apostle Paul takes this even further. In Ephesians 2, he describes Jesus as the one who has broken down the dividing wall between Jew and Gentile. His language is astonishing: Jesus has made the two into one. Not one because they have become identical, but one because Christ has created something new: one new humanity.

This matters because the church is supposed to be a demonstration of what Jesus has accomplished. The gospel does not simply tell us that reconciliation is possible; the church is called to embody reconciliation. Paul says something similar in Galatians 3. In Christ, the old distinctions people used to rank and separate themselves—Jew and Greek, slave and free, male and female—no longer determine their worth or their belonging. Our differences do not disappear, but they no longer have the power to decide who belongs.

Unity, then, is not the absence of disagreement. It is the presence of a deeper allegiance that enables us to remain together through disagreement. We do not have to agree about everything to belong to one another. We do not have to become the same to love one another. Our shared life is rooted in Christ, not in our ability to share the same preferences or opinions.

The church becomes a place where people can say: “You don't have to become like me for me to love you.” “We don't have to agree about everything to belong to one another.” “We can be different and still be family.”

Jesus says that kind of unity has missional significance. In John 17, he prays that his followers would be one, as the Father and Son are one. And why does he pray that prayer? “So that the world may believe.” Think about that. Our unity is not just for us. Our reconciliation is part of our witness to the world around us.

Imagine a community like that: people from different backgrounds genuinely loving one another; a place where disagreement does not automatically mean separation; a place where people can look around and wonder, “Why are these people together?” And the answer is: Jesus. That would be a powerful witness. The world knows how to divide. What if the church became a place where people could see a community that is one, though different?

Perhaps Christians learning to live together in unity would make God more believable in our society. Perhaps the Lord would add to those communities daily those who are being saved.

Of course, we will not always get this right. We will wound one another, misunderstand one another and sometimes fail to make room for difference. A counter-community is not a community that never gets things wrong. It is a community that learns to repent, forgive, seek reconciliation and begin again. Grace is not an optional extra; it is what makes this shared life possible.

Think about Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane. He takes his disciples with him and asks them to stay awake and watch with him as he faces the most agonising moments of his life. Yet they repeatedly fall asleep. He returns to find them sleeping, not once but three times. They let him down at the very moment he needs them most. And yet Jesus doesn't abandon them. Even knowing their weakness, even knowing that they will soon scatter and deny him, he continues towards the cross for them. And after the resurrection, he gathers them again and restores their calling. What a beautiful picture of grace.

Perhaps this is what counter-community looks like. Not a group of people who never disappoint one another, but a people who learn to keep returning to one another. People who don't give up on each other when things become difficult. People who make room for failure, offer forgiveness and allow grace to shape their relationships.

In the next post, we will look at the cry of anxiety and ask what it might mean for the church to embody peace.


 

Countering the cry of the community part 1: What are people looking for?

 

COUNTERING THE CRY OF THE COMMUNITY

What are people looking for?

From doing church well to becoming a different kind of people

 

It was Saturday 19 May 2018, and we had just completed our first year of missional listening. The posture of listening had made us more attentive to noticing things in everyday life. We sat down as a family to watch the royal wedding—Harry and Meghan. I am a bit of a republican at heart, but watch it I did, persuaded by my young daughters, all dressed as bridesmaids!

You may remember the sermon. It was very un-royal-like! Bishop Michael Curry preached with passion, vibrancy and charisma as he spoke beautifully about love. What I noticed came afterwards. As I went onto social media, I saw my Christian friends waxing lyrical about the sermon. “Expect the churches to be full tomorrow—the Gospel has just been presented incredibly to millions around the globe.” I even heard the lament: “If only I could preach like him, my church would be full.” Everywhere I looked, Christians were excited about the sermon and what it might mean for the church on Sunday morning.

I spend a lot of time with people who are not part of a church community, so I decided to ask some of those who had watched the sermon what they thought. “Long!” (It was about ten minutes.) “Boring.” “Irrelevant.” These were just some of the replies. Nobody I spoke to was planning to attend church because they had heard this great sermon.

That moment felt like an epiphany. All my Christian life, I—and many others—had been trying to make church more attractive. We have talked about getting the preaching right, the website right, the best coffee, a funky new worship band or the good old organ back. We have trained welcome teams, employed youth workers and developed programmes. All with good intentions. Yet the people we are trying to attract may not be waiting for us to do church better. They may not be looking for a more polished version of something they have already decided is not for them.

So I began to wonder: what if people are not waiting for us to do church well? What if they are longing to experience something different from ordinary life? Something otherworldly? Perhaps people are looking for a different way of being human. And perhaps the most compelling invitation the church can offer is not simply a better service, but a glimpse of a different kind of community.

The churches I serve have three metaphors we try to live by: Candle, Table and Door. Candle speaks of worship and the presence of God; Table speaks of one-anothering and life together as family; Door speaks of blessing our communities and being witnesses in everyday life.

We find worship relatively easy to understand. We praise God in our gatherings and in our everyday lives. We understand the need for mission as we see the brokenness of the world and dream of partnering with God in ushering in his shalom. But fellowship can be harder to grasp. How are we actually meant to live together as Christians?

People are complicated. We have different personalities, backgrounds, opinions, politics, expectations and ways of doing things. Yet when we read the Bible, it is astonishing how much God seems to care about togetherness.

God creates a people. One thing we can easily forget, especially in the evangelical world, is that God's plan has never simply been to save individuals. From the beginning, God has been creating a people. He calls Abraham not simply to bless Abraham, but to create through him a people who will become a blessing to the nations. Israel is called to be a people. Jesus does not simply gather individuals who privately believe in him; he creates a community. He calls twelve disciples and sends them out together. He teaches them how to live with one another. After Pentecost, Acts 2 gives us an extraordinary picture of what happens when the Holy Spirit creates a people.

They devote themselves to the apostles' teaching and to fellowship; they eat together, pray together, share what they have, care for those in need and worship with glad and sincere hearts. Then Luke gives us the most remarkable sentence: “The Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved.” Incredible.

I wonder whether, as churches, we sometimes read Acts 2 the wrong way round. We concentrate on adding to our number, hoping that if we get our services, programmes and outreach right, people will come. But perhaps we are called first to concentrate on becoming family—a people shaped by the Spirit—and to trust God with the growth. In Acts 2, the community itself has become part of the proclamation. People can see something. They can experience something. They can walk into something. They encounter a different way of being human.

This is not an argument against preaching, evangelism or inviting people to explore faith. These things matter. It is a question of what gives them their substance. The words we proclaim are to be made visible in the life we share. The church is not merely a gathering that delivers a message; it is a people whose common life is meant to make that message tangible.

In the next post in this series, I want to introduce the idea of the “cries of our communities”. We will look at how churches can sometimes mimic those cries, and what it might mean to repent of that mimicry and become a counter-community—a people who reveal a different way of being human.

And as we begin to yearn and work towards this kind of community, may the Lord begin to add to our number daily those who are being saved.